Tamra Rosenfeld
Meal replacement bars are geared towards athletes who need quick energy or people on the go who do not have time to have a meal.
Pros to meal replacement bars: They are better than stopping at McDonalds or Burger King. It is also better to have a meal replacement bar than to skip a meal. Skipping meals can slow metabolism.
Cons to meal replacement bars: They can be high in calories, sugars, and fats (including saturated fat). Many people use them as snacks which can be detrimental to weight loss and weight maintenance. These bars may contain anywhere between 150 and 350 calories. A serving of fruit is 60 calories; Dannon Light N Fit yogurt only contains 60 calories. Combine a fruit and a light yogurt and you still have fewer calories than a meal replacement bar. Meal replacement bars also do not contain all of the nutrients a well balanced meal would provide.
Other comments: Meal replacement bars are usually high in protein. The average person in America consumes more protein than they need from their diet. If being used for a meal replacement the high protein content can be beneficial, but if used as a snack it is probably not needed. Many meal replacement bars are fortified with 100% of the RDA for some vitamins and minerals. With a well balanced diet this fortification is not necessary. In addition if you have 2 meal replacement bars a day and a bowl of fortified cereal in the morning you may be getting 3 times what is recommended for some vitamins and minerals.
How should you chose a meal replacement bar? If you are going to have a meal replacement bar here are the things to look for:
- Read the labels and look at the calorie content.
- Check the amount of fat and saturated fat on the label. Look for under 30% of the bar coming from fat. Look for 1 gram of saturated fat or less.
- Look for added sugar.
- Look for stimulant such as caffeine that you may not want.
- Check the fiber content – the higher the fiber, the better.
Meal replacement bar examples:
Below are examples of some protein bars that are very high in calories, fat, or sugar.
High calorie bars (over 300 calories per bar) –
American Body Building Extreme Body Peanut Crunch Bar,
Detour Caramel Peanut,
Meso-Tech Caramel Nut Crunch,
Myoplex Storm Chocolate Peanut Caramel,
Tri-O-Plex Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip.
High fat bars (10 grams of fat or more):
Atkins Advantage Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar,
Carb Solutions High Protein Bar Creamy Chocolate Peanut Butter,
Detour Caramel Peanut,
Myoplex Storm Chocolate Peanut Caramel,
Tri-O-Plex Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip.
High sugar bars (25 grams of sugar or more):
Advant Edge Complete Nutrition Energy Bar Peanut Butter Caramel,
American Body Building Steel Bar Crunchy Peanut Butter,
GeniSoy Southern Style Chunky Peanut Butter Fudge,
Promax Chocolate Peanut Crunch.
Here are some better options:
If you are looking for a lower calorie (under 200), lower fat (5 grams or less), and lower sugar (15 grams or less) option:
Doctor’s CarbRite Diet Chocolate Peanut Butter,
Kashi Go Lean Crunchy Chocolate Peanut Bliss,
Luna Nutz Over Chocolate,
Pria from Power Bar Chocolate Peanut Crunch,
Rapid Results Diet System Soy Protein Bar Chocolate Almond,
Slim Fast Succeed Chocolate Peanut,
If you are an athlete looking for quick energy these are high in calories and carbohydrates but low in saturated fat which can raise cholesterol levels:
Biochem Ultimate Low Carb Bar – Creamy Peanut Butter
Cliff Bar Chocolate Chip Peanut Crunch
Power Bar Chocolate Peanut Butter
Revival – Peanut Butter Chocolate Pal
Tri-O-Plex Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip